Car Reviews Are Out of Touch

Опубликовано 17 января 2026, 15:00

Car reviews are out of touch with the people who actually buy cars. But how much of the blame falls on automotive journalists alone? In this episode of Fuel for Thought, I take a hard look at modern car reviews, automotive journalism, and car media, and explain why so many consumers no longer trust the people reviewing cars online and in print. From “price as tested” discrepancies and press car culture, to reviewers who don’t own cars, short-term testing, and algorithm-driven hyperbole, this essay breaks down where the disconnect comes from and how it happened.

This isn’t about calling out individual creators or publications. It’s about examining how car reviews are made, who they’re really for, and whether automotive journalists still serve a meaningful consumer function, or if they’ve become mostly entertainment. I also reflect on my own role as an automotive journalist, how YouTube algorithms shape content, and what reviewers, myself included, can do to rebuild trust, provide better information, and make reviews that actually help people decide what car to buy while providing a show entertaining enough to watch in the first place.

Referenced video: The Carmudgeon Show (Ep. 24): youtu.be/dVu97G-NVqY?si=OKPeK_...

If you enjoy the show, Patreon is the best way to keep it going: patreon.com/regularcarreviews

Shirts and Mugs: regularcars-shop.fourthwall.co...
Key tags and plate frames: zazzle.com/store/regularcars
Find RCR online:
BlueSky: @regularcars / @theromannick
Instagram: @regularcarreviews / @theromannick
Linktree: linktr.ee/regularcarreviews
Second channel: youtube.com/@RegularandRoman
Thank you for supporting Regular Car Reviews!

Timestamps:
00:00 I’m an Automotive Journalist (And I’m Part of the Problem)
01:57 Intro Theme
02:07 People Don’t Trust Car Reviews Anymore
03:36 The “Price As Tested” Lie
07:06 Who Are These Car Reviews Even For?
10:02 Not All Journalists Own Cars
12:40 Short-Term Testing, Long-Term Questions
16:27 Enter the Algorithm
19:58 Performative Content Fatigue Is Killing Trust
22:00 Everyone Is An Automotive Journalist
29:36 What Can We Do Better?